Introductory Note
In 1656, Cromwell issued a proclamation for a general fast to consider the cause of
the continued distracted condition of Britain. In response, Sir Henry Vane, previously
Governor of Massachusetts, and one of the most high minded statesmen of the period of the
Commonwealth in England, published the following tract, expounding the principles of civil
and religious liberty, and proposing that method of forming a constitution, through a
convention called for the purpose, which was actually followed in America after the
Revolution.
A Healing Question
Part II
A Healing Question propounded and resolved, upon Occasion of the late public and
seasonable Call to Humiliation, in order to Love and Union among the honest Party, and
with a Desire to apply Balm to the Wound before it become incurable.
The question propounded is, What possibility doth yet remain (all things considered) of
reconciling and uniting the dissenting judgments of honest men within the three nations,
who still pretend to agree in the spirit, justice, and reason of the same good cause, and
what is the means to effect this?
Answ. If it be taken for granted (as, on the magistrate's part, from the ground
inviting the people of England and Wales to a solemn day of fasting and humiliation, may
not be despaired of) that all the dissenting parties agree still in the spirit and reason
of the same righteous cause, the resolution seems very clear in the affirmative; arguing
not only for a possibility, but a great probability hereof; nay, a necessity daily
approaching nearer and nearer to compel it, if any or all of the dissenting parties intend
or desire to be safe from the danger of the common enemy, who is not out of work, though
at present much out of sight and observation.
The grounds of this are briefly these: First, the cause hath still the same goodness in
it as ever, and is, or ought to be, as much in the hearts of all good people that have
adhered to it: it is not less to be valued now, than when neither blood nor treasure were
thought too dear to carry it on, and hold it up from sinking; and hath the same omnipotent
God, whose great name is concerned in it, as well as his people's outward safety and
welfare; who knows, also, how to give a revival to it when secondary instruments and
visible means fail or prove deceitful.
Secondly, The persons concerned and engaged in this cause are still the same as before,
with the advantage of being more tried, more inured to danger and hardship, and more
endeared to one another, by their various and great experiences, as well of their own
hearts as their fellow-brethren. These are the same still in heart and desire after the
same thing, which is, that, being freed out of the hands of their enemies. they may serve
the Lord without fear, in holiness and righteousness all the days of their life.
As they have had this great good finally in their aims (if declarations to men and
appeals to God signify anything), so, as a requisite to attain this, they did with great
cheerfulness and unanimity draw out themselves to the utmost in the maintenance of a war,
when all other means, first essayed, proved ineffectual. In the management of this war, it
pleased God, the righteous Judge (who was appealed to in the controversy), so to bless the
counsel and forces of the persons concerned and engaged in this cause, as in the end to
make them absolute and complete conquerors over their common enemy; and by this means they
had added unto the natural right which was in them before (and so declared by their
representatives in Parliament assembled), the right of conquest, for the strengthening of
their just claim to be governed by national councils, and successive representatives of
their own election and setting up. This they once thought they had been in possession of,
when it was ratified, as it were, in the blood of the last king. But of late a great
interruption having happened unto them in their former expectations, and, instead thereof,
something rising up that seems rather accommodated to the private and selfish interest of
a particular part (in comparison) than truly adequate to the common good and concern of
the whole body engaged in this cause: hence it is that this compacted body is now falling
asunder into many dissenting parts (a thing not unforeseen nor unhoped for by the common
enemy all along as their last relief); and if these breaches be not timely healed, and the
offences (before they take too deep root) removed, they will certainly work more to the
advantage of the common enemy than any of their own unwearied endeavours and dangerous
contrivances in foreign parts put all together.
A serious discussion and sober enlarging upon these grounds will quickly give an
insight into the state of the question, and naturally tend to a plain and familiar
resolution thereof.
That which is first to be opened is the nature and goodness of the cause; which, had it
not carried in it its own evidence, would scarce have found so many of the people of God
adherers to it within the three nations, contributing either their counsels, their purses,
their bodily pains, or their affections and prayers, as a combined strength; without
which, the military force alone would have been little available to subdue the common
enemy, and restore to this whole body their just natural rights in civil things, and true
freedom in matters of conscience.
The two last-mentioned particulars, rightly stated, will evidence sufficiently the
nature and goodness of this cause.
For the first of these, that is to say, the natural right, which the whole party of
honest men adhering to this cause are by success of their arms restored unto, fortified
in, and may claim as their undeniable privilege, that righteously cannot be taken from
them, nor they debarred from bringing into exercise, it lies in this:
They are to have and enjoy the freedom (by way of dutiful compliance and condescension
from all the parts and members of this society) so set up meet persons in the place of
supreme judicature and authority among them, whereby they may have the use and benefit of
the choicest light and wisdom of the nation that they are capable to call forth, for the
rule and government under which they will live; and through the orderly exercise of such
measure of wisdom and counsel as the Lord in this way shall please to give unto them, to
shape and form all subordinate actings and administrations of rule and government so as
shall best answer the public welfare and safety of the whole.
This, in substance, is the right and freedom contained in the nature and goodness of
the cause wherein the honest party have been engaged; for in this all the particulars of
our civil right and freedom are comprehended, conserved in, and derived from their proper
root; in which, while they grow, they will ever thrive, flourish, and increase; whereas,
on the contrary, if there be never so many fair branches of liberty planted on the root of
a private and selfish interest, they will not long prosper, but must, within a little
time, wither and degenerate into the nature of that whereinto they are planted; and hence,
indeed, sprung the evil of that government which rose in and with the Norman Conquest.
The root and bottom upon which it stood was not public interest, but the private lust
and will of the conqueror, who by force of arms did at first detain the right and freedom
which was and is due to the whole body of the people; for whose safety and good,
government itself is ordained by God, not for the particular benefit of the rulers, as a
distinct and private interest of their own; which yet, for the most part, is not only
preferred before the common good, but upheld in opposition thereunto. And as at first the
conqueror did, by violence and force, deny this freedom to the people, which was their
natural right and privilege, so he and his successors all along lay as bars and
impediments to the true national interest and public good, in the very national councils
and assemblies themselves, which were constituted in such a manner as most served for the
upholding of the private interest of their families; and this being challenged by them as
their prerogative, was found by the people assembled in Parliament most unrighteous,
burdensome, and destructive to their liberty. And when they once perceived that by this
engine all their just rights were like to be destroyed especially (being backed, as it
was, with the power of the militia, which the late king, for that purpose, had assumed
into his hands, and would not, upon the people's application to him in Parliament, part
with into the hands of that great council, who were best to be intrusted with the nation's
safety), this was the ground of the quarrel, upon a civil account between the king and his
party, and the whole body of adherents to the cause of the people's true liberty; whereof
this short touch hath been given, and shall suffice for the opening of the first branch of
this clause.
The second branch which remains briefly to be handled is that which also upon the
grounds of natural right is to be laid claim unto, but distinguishes itself from the
former as it respects a more heavenly and excellent object wherein the freedom is to be
exercised and enjoyed, that is to say, matters of religion, or that concern the service
and worship of God.
Unto this freedom the nations of the world have right and title by the purchase of
Christ's blood, who, by virtue of his death and resurrection, is become the sole Lord and
Ruler in and over the conscience; for to this end Christ died, rose, and revived, that he
might be Lord both of the dead and of the living, and that every one might give an account
of himself, in all matters of God's worship unto God and Christ alone, as their own
Master, unto whom they stand or fall in judgment, and are not in these things to be
oppressed, or brought before the judgment-seats of men. For why shouldst thou set at
naught thy brother in matters of his faith and conscience, and herein intrude into the
proper office of Christ, since we are all to stand at the judgment-seat of Christ, whether
governors or governed, and by his decision only are capable of being declared with
certainty to be in the right or in the wrong?
By virtue, then, of this supreme law, sealed and confirmed in the blood of Christ unto
all men (whose souls he challenges a propriety in, to bring under his inward rule in the
service and worship of God), it is that all magistrates are to fear and forbear
intermeddling with giving rule or imposing in those matters. They are to content
themselves with what is plain in their commission, as ordained of God to be his minister
unto men for good, while they approve themselves the doers of that which is good in the
sight of men, and whereof earthly and worldly judicatures are capable to make a clear and
perfect judgment: in which case the magistrate is to be for praise and protection to them.
In like manner, he is to be a minister of terror and revenge to those that do evil in
matters of outward practice, converse, and dealings in the things of this life between man
and man, for the cause whereof the judicatures of men are appointed and set up. But to
exceed these limits, as it is not safe or warrantable for the magistrate (in that he who
is higher than the highest, regards, and will show himself displeased at it), so neither
is it good for the people, who hereby are nourished up in a biting, devouring, wrathful
spirit one against another, and are found transgressors of that royal law which forbids us
to do that unto another which we would not have them do unto us, were we in their
condition.
This freedom, then, is of high concern to be had and enjoyed, as well for the
magistrate's sake as for the people's common good; and it consists, as hath been said, in
the magistrate forbearing to put forth the power of rule and coercion in things that God
hath exempted out of his commission: so that all care requisite for the people's obtaining
this may be exercised with great ease, if it be taken in its proper season, and that this
restraint be laid upon the supreme power before it be erected, as a fundamental
constitution, among others, upon which the free consent of the people is given, to have
the persons brought into the exercise of supreme authority over them and on their behalf;
and if, besides, as a further confirmation hereunto, it be acknowledged the voluntary act
of the ruling power, when once brought into a capacity of acting legislatively, that
herein they are bound up, and judge it their duty so to be (both in reference to God, the
institutor of magistracy, and in reference to the whole body by whom they are intrusted),
this great blessing will hereby be so well provided for that we shall have no cause to
fear, as it may be ordered.
By this means a great part of the outward exercise of anti-Christian tyranny and
bondage will be plucked up by the very roots, which, till some such course be held in it,
will be always apt to renew and sprout out afresh, under some new form or refined
appearances, as by late years' experience we have been taught: for, since the fall of the
bishops and persecuting presbyteries, the same spirit is apt to arise in the next sort of
clergy that can get the ear of the magistrate, and pretend to the keeping and ruling the
conscience of the governors, although this spirit and practice hath been all along decried
by the faithful adherents to this cause as a most sore oppression and insufferable yoke of
bondage, most unrighteously kept up over the consciences of the people, and therefore
judged by them most needful to be taken out of the way; and in this matter the present
governors have been willing very eminently to give their testimony in their public
declarations, however in practice there is much of grievance yet found among us, though
more, in probability, from the officiousness of subordinate ministers than any clear
purpose or design of the chief in power.
Having thus showed what the true freedom is, in both the branches of it, that shines
forth in the righteous cause, wherein the good people of these nations have so deeply
engaged, it will not be improper, in the next place, to consider two particulars more that
give still farther light into the matter in question, as, first, the qualifications of the
persons that have adhered to this cause; secondly, the capacity wherein they have been
found from time to time carrying it on.
As to their qualification, they have, in the general, distinguished themselves and been
made known by a forwardness to assist and own the public welfare and good of the nation,
for the attaining and preserving the just rights and liberties thereof, asserted and
witnessed unto in the true stating of this cause, according to the two branches thereof
already spoken to. They have showed themselves, upon all occasions, desirers and lovers of
true freedom, either in civils or in spirituals, or in both. To express their value
thereof, and faithfulness to the same, they have largely contributed, in one kind or
other, what was proper to each in his place to do; which actions of theirs proceeding from
hearts sincerely affected to the cause, created in them a right to be of an incorporation
and society by themselves, under the name of the good party, having been from the
beginning unto this day publicly and commonly so acknowledged, by way of distinction from
all neuters, close and open enemies, and deceitful friends or apostates. These, in order
to the maintaining of this cause, have stood by the army, in defence and support thereof,
against all opposition whatever, as those that, by the growing light of these times, have
been taught and led forth in their experiences to look above and beyond the letter, form,
and outward circumstances of government, into the inward reason and spirit thereof, herein
only to fix and terminate, to the leaving behind all empty shadows that would obtrude
themselves in the place of true freedom.
Secondly, as to the capacity wherein these persons, thus qualified, have acted, it hath
been very variable, and subject to great changes: sometimes in one form, and sometimes in
another, and very seldom, if ever at all, so exactly and in all points consonant to the
rule of former laws and constitutions of government as to be clearly and fully justified
by them any longer than the law of success and conquest did uphold them who had the inward
warrant of justice and righteousness to encourage them in such their actings.
The utmost and last reserve, therefore, which they have had, in case all other failed,
hath been their military capacity, not only strictly taken for the standing army, but in
the largest sense, wherein the whole party may (with the army, and under that military
constitution and conduct which, by the providence of God, they shall then be found in)
associate themselves in the best order they can for the common defence and safety of the
whole; as not ignorant that when once embodied in this their military posture, in such
manner as by common consent shall be found requisite for the safety of the body, they are
most irresistible, absolute, and comprehensive in their power, having that wherein the
substance of all government is contained, and under the protection whereof, and safety
that may be maintained thereby, they can contrive and determine in what manner this
irresistible, absolute, and boundless power, unto which they are now arrived in this their
military capacity, shall have just and due limits set unto it, and be drawn out in a meet
and orderly way of exercise for the commonweal and safety of the whole body, under the
rule and oversight of a supreme judicature, unto the wisdom of whose laws and orders the
sword is to become most entirely subject and subservient; and this without the least cause
of jealousy or unsafety, either to the standing army, or any member thereof, or unto the
good people adhering to this cause, or any of them, since the interest of both, by this
mutual action of either, will be so combined together in one (even in that wherein before
they were distinct), that all just cause of difference, fear, animosity, emulation,
jealousy, or the like, will be wholly abolished and removed.
For when once the whole body of the good people find that the military interest and
capacity is their own, and that into which necessity at the last may bring the whole party
(whereof, of right, a place is to be reserved for them), and that herein they are so far
from being in subjection or slavery, that in this posture they are most properly
sovereign, and possess their right of natural sovereignty, they will presently see a
necessity of continuing ever one with their army, raised and maintained by them for the
promoting this cause against the common enemy, who in his next attempt will put for all
with greater desperateness and rage than ever.
Again, when once the standing army and their governors shall also find that, by setting
and keeping up themselves in a divided interest from the rest of the body of honest men,
they withhold from themselves those contributions in all voluntary and cheerful
assistances, by the affections and prayers, by the persons and purses of the good party,
to the weakening themselves thereby, as to any vigorous support from them, in the times of
most imminent danger (whereof the late king had an experience, that will not suddenly be
out of memory, when he undertook the war, in the beginning of these troubles, against the
Scots, and was, in a manner, therein deserted by all the good party in England), they will
then find (if they stay not till it be too late) that, by espousing the interest of the
people, in submitting themselves with their fellow-adherents to the cause, under the rule
and authority of their own supreme judicature, they lose not their power or sovereignty,
but, becoming one civil or politic incorporation with the whole party of honest men, they
do therein keep the sovereignty, as originally seated in themselves, and part with it only
but as by deputation and representation of themselves, when it is brought into an orderly
way of exercise, by being put into the hands of persons chosen and intrusted by themselves
to that purpose.
By this mutual and happy transition, which may be made between the party of honest men
in the three nations virtually in arms, and those actually so now in power at the head of
the army; how suddenly would the union of the whole body be consolidated, and made so firm
as it will not need to fear all the designs and attempts of the common enemy, especially
if herein they unite themselves in the first place to the Lord, as willing to follow his
providence, and observe his will in the way and manner of bringing this to pass! in which
case we shall not need to fear what all the gates of hell are able to do in opposition
thereunto.
It is not, then, the standing and being of the present army and military forces in the
three nations that is liable to exception of offence from any dissenting judgments at this
time among the honest, well-affected party. In and with them, under God, stand the welfare
and outward safety of the whole body; and to be enemies to them, or wish them hurt, were
to do it to themselves; and, by trying such conclusions, to play the game of the common
enemy, to the utter ruin and destruction, not only of the true freedom aimed at and
contended for in the late wars, but of the very persons themselves that have been in any
sort active or eminent promoters thereof.
The army, considered as it is in the hands of an honest and wise general, and sober,
faithful officers, embodied with the rest of the party of honest men, and espousing still
the same cause, and acting in their primitive simplicity, humility, and trust, in
reference to the welfare and safety of the whole body, is the only justifiable and most
advantageous posture and capacity that the good party at present can find themselves in,
in order to the obtaining that true freedom they have fought for, and possessing of it in
the establishment thereof upon the true basis and foundation, as hath been showed, of
right government.
That wherein the offence lies, and which causes such great thoughts of heart among the
honest party (if it may be freely expressed, as sure it may, when the magistrate himself
professes he doth but desire and wait for conviction therein), is, in short, this:
That when the right and privilege is returned, nay, is restored by conquest unto the
whole body (that forfeited not their interest therein), of freely disposing themselves in
such a constitution of righteous government as may best answer the ends held forth in this
cause; that, nevertheless, either through delay they should be withheld as they are, or
through design they should come at last to be utterly denied the exercise of this their
right, upon pretence that they are not in capacity as yet to use it, which, indeed, hath
some truth in it, if those that are now in power, and have the command of the arms, do not
prepare all things requisite thereunto, as they may, and, like faithful guardians to the
Commonwealth, admitted to be in its nonage, they ought.
But if the bringing of true freedom into exercise among men, yea, so refined a party of
men, be impossible, why hath this been concealed all this while? and why was it not
thought on before so much blood was spilt, and treasure spent? Surely such a thing as this
was judged real and practicable, not imaginary and notional.
Besides, why may it not suffice to have been thus long delayed and withheld from the
whole body, at least as to its being brought by them into exercise now at last? Surely the
longer it is withheld, the stronger jealousies do increase, that it is intended to be
assumed and engrossed by a part only, to the leaving the rest of the body (who, in all
reason and justice, ought to be equally participants with the other in the right and
benefit of the conquest, for as much as the war managed at the expense and for the safety
of the whole) in a condition almost as much exposed, and subject to be imposed upon, as if
they had been enemies and conquered, not in any sense conquerors.
If ever such an unrighteous, unkind, and deceitful dealing with brethren should happen,
although it might continue above the reach of question from human judicature, yet can we
think it possible it should escape and go unpunished by the immediate hand of the
righteous Judge of the whole world, when he ariseth out of his place to do right to the
oppressed.
Nay, if, instead of favouring and promoting the people's common good and welfare,
self-interest and private gain should evidently appear to be the things we have aimed at
all along; if those very tyrannical principles and anti-Christian relics, which God by us
hath punished in our predecessors, should again revive, spring up afresh, and show
themselves lodged also and retained in our bosoms, rendering us of the number of those
that have forgot they were purged from their old sins, and declaring us to be such as, to
please a covetous mind, do withhold from destruction that which God hath designed to the
curse of his vengeance: if all those great advantages of serving the Lord's will and
design in procuring and advancing his people's true welfare and outward safety, which (as
the fruit of his blessing upon our armies) have so miraculously fallen into our hands,
shall at last be wrested and misimproved to the enriching and greatening of ourselves - if
these things should ever be found among us (which the Lord in mercy forbid!), shall we
need to look any farther for the accursed thing? will not our consciences show us, from
the light of the Word and Spirit of God, how near a conformity these actions would hold
therewith? which sin (Josh., vii.) became a curse to the camp, and withheld the Lord from
being any more among them, or going out with their forces. And did the action of Achan
import any more than these two things: First, he saved and kept from destruction the
goodly Babylonish garment, which was devoted by God thereunto; secondly, he brought not in
the fruit and gain of the conquest into the Lord's treasury, but covetously went about to
convert it to his own proper use? To do this is to take of the accursed thing, which
(Josh., vii.) all Israel was said to do in the sin of Achan, and to have stolen and
dissembled likewise, and put it among their own stuff. This caused the anger of the Lord
to kindle against Israel, and made them unable to stand before their enemies, but their
hearts melted as water. And thus far the Lord is concerned, if such an evil as this shall
lie hid in the midst of us. But to return to what we were upon before.
Part II
The matter which is in question among the dissenting parts of the whole body of honest
men is not so trivial and of such small consequence as some would make it. 'Tis, in
effect, the main and whole of the cause; without which all the freedom which the people
have or can have is in comparison but shadow and in name only, and therefore can never
give that peace and satisfaction to the body which is requisite unto a durable and solid
settlement. This is that which makes all sound and safe at the root, and gives the right
balance necessary to be held up between sovereignty and subjection in the exercise of all
righteous government; applying the use of the sword to the promoting and upholding the
public safety and welfare of the whole body, in preference, and, if need be, in opposition
unto any of the parts; while yet, by its equal and impartial administration in reference
unto each, it doth withal maintain the whole body in a most delightful harmony, welfare,
and correspondency. The sword never can, nor is it to be expected ever will do this, while
the sovereignty is admitted and placed anywhere else than in the whole body of the people
that have adhered to the cause, and by them be derived unto their successive
representatives, as the most equal and impartial judicature for the effecting hereof.
Where there is, then, a righteous and good constitution of government, there is first,
an orderly union of many understandings together, as the public and common supreme
judicature or visible sovereignty, set in a way of free and orderly exercise, for the
directing and applying the use of the ruling power or the sword, to promote the interest
and common welfare of the whole, without any disturbance or annoyance from within or from
without; and then, secondly, there is a like union and readiness of will in all the
individuals, in their private capacities, to execute and obey (by all the power requisite,
and that they are able to put forth) those sovereign laws and orders issued out by their
own deputies and trustees.
A supreme judicature, thus made the representative of the whole, is that which, we say,
will most naturally care, and most equally provide for the common good and safety. Though
by this it is not denied but that the supreme power, when by free consent 'tis placed in a
single person or in some few persons, may be capable also to administer righteous
government; at least, the body that gives this liberty, when they need not, are to thank
themselves if it prove otherwise. But when this free and natural access unto government is
interrupted and declined, so as a liberty is taken by any particular member, or number of
them, that are to be reputed but a part in comparison of the whole, to assume and engross
the office of sovereign rule and power, and to impose themselves as the competent public
judge of the safety and good of the whole, without their free and due consent, and to lay
claim unto this, as those that find themselves possessed of the sword (and that so
advantageously as it cannot be recovered again out of their hands without more apparent
danger and damage to the whole body than such attempts are worth), this is that anarchy
that is the first rise and step to tyranny, and lays grounds of manifest confusion and
disorder, exposing the ruling power to the next hand that on the next opportunity can lay
hold on the sword, and so, by a kind of necessity, introduces the highest imposition and
bondage upon the whole body, in compelling all the parts, though never so much against the
true public interest, to serve and obey, as their sovereign rule and supreme authority,
the arbitrary will and judgment of those that bring themselves into rule by the power of
the sword, in the right only of a part that sets up itself in preference before, or at
least in competition with, the welfare of the whole.
And if this, which is so essential to the wellbeing and right constitution of
government, were once obtained, the disputes about the form would not prove so difficult,
nor find such opposition, as to keeping the bone of contention and disunion, with much
danger to the whole; for if, as the foundation of all, the sovereignty be acknowledged to
reside originally in the whole body of adherents to this cause (whose natural and inherent
right thereunto is of a far ancienter date than what is obtained by success of their arms,
and so cannot be abrogated even by conquest itself, if that were the case), and then if,
in consequence hereof, a supreme judicature be set up and orderly constituted, as
naturally arising and resulting from the free choice and consent of the whole body taken
out from among themselves, as flesh of their flesh and bone of their bone, of the same
public spirit and nature with themselves, and the main be by this means secured, what
could be propounded afterward as to the form of administration that would much stick?
Would a standing council of state, settled for life, in reference to the safety of the
Commonwealth, and for the maintaining intercourse and commerce with foreign states, under
the inspection and oversight of the supreme judicature, but of the same fundamental
constitution with themselves - would this be disliked? admitting their orders were
binding, in the intervals of supreme national assemblies, so far only as consonant to the
settled laws of the Commonwealth, the vacancy of any of which, by death or otherwise,
might be supplied by the vote of the major part of themselves: nay, would there be any
just exception to be taken if (besides both these) it should be agreed (as another part of
the fundamental constitution of the government) to place that branch of sovereignty which
chiefly respects the execution of laws in a distinct office from that of the legislative
power (and yet subordinate to them and to the laws), capable to be intrusted into the
hands of one single person, if need require, or in a greater number, as the legislative
power should think fit; and, for the greater strength and honour unto this office, that
the execution of all laws and orders (that are binding) may go forth in his or their name,
and all disobedience thereunto, or contempt thereof, be taken as done to the people's
sovereignty, whereof he or they bear the image or representation, subordinate to the
legislative power, and at their will to be kept up and continued in the hands of a single
person or more, as the experience of the future good or evil of it shall require?
Would such an office as this, thus stated, carry in it any inconsistency with a free
state? Nay, if it be well considered, would it not rather be found of excellent use to the
wellbeing of magistracy, founded upon this righteous bottom, that such a lieutenancy of
the people's sovereignty in these three nations may always reside in some one or more
person, in whose administration that which is reward and punishment may shine forth?
And if now it shall be objected that (notwithstanding all these cautions), should once
this sovereignty be acknowledged to be in the diffused body of the people (though the
adherents to this cause, not only as their natural, but as their acquired right by
conquest), they would suddenly put the use and exercise of the legislative power into such
hands as would, through their ill qualifiedness to the work, spoil all by
mal-administration thereof, and hereby lose the cause instead of upholding and maintaining
it.
The answer unto this is, first, that God, by his providence, hath eased our minds much
in this solicitude by the course he hath already taken to fit and prepare a choice and
selected number of the people unto this work, that are tried and refined by their inward
and outward experiences in this great quarrel, and the many changes they have passed
through; in respect whereof well qualified persons are to be found, if due care be but
taken in the choice of them. And if herein this people of the Lord shall be waiting upon
him for his guidance and presence with them, we may have grounds and hope that God (whose
name hath all along been called upon in the maintaining of this cause) will pour out so
abundantly of his spirit upon his people attending on him in righteous ways, and will also
move their hearts to choose persons bearing his image into the magistracy, that a more
glorious product may spring up out of this than at first we can expect, to the setting up
of the Lord himself as chief judge and lawgiver among us. And unto this the wisdom and
honesty of the persons now in power may have an opportunity eminently to come into
discovery; for in this case, and upon the grounds already laid, the very persons now in
power are they unto whose lot it would fall to set about this preparatory work, and by
their orders and directions to dispose the whole body, and bring them into the meetest
capacity to effect the same, the most natural way for which would seem to be by a general
council, or convention of faithful, honest, and discerning men, chosen for that purpose by
the free consent of the whole body of adherents to this cause in the several parts of the
nations, and observing the time and place of meeting appointed to them (with other
circumstances concerning their election) by order from the present ruling power, but
considered as general of the army:
Which convention is not properly to exercise the legislative power, but only to debate
freely, and agree upon the particulars that by way of fundamental constitutions shall be
laid and inviolably observed as the conditions upon which the whole body so represented
doth consent to cast itself into as civil and politic incorporation, and under the visible
form and administration of government therein declared, and to be by each individual
member of the body subscribed in testimony of his or their particular consent given
thereunto: which conditions so agreed (and among them an Act of Oblivion for one) will be
without danger of being broken or departed from, considering of what it is they are the
conditions, and the nature of the convention wherein they are made, which is of the people
represented in their highest state of sovereignty, as they have the sword in their hands
unsubjected unto the rules of civil government, but what themselves orderly assembled for
that purpose do think fit to make. And the sword, upon these conditions, subjecting itself
to the supreme judicature thus to be set up, how suddenly might harmony, righteousness,
love, peace, and safety unto the whole body follow hereupon, as the happy fruit of such a
settlement, if the Lord have any delight to be among us!
And this once put in a way, and declared for by the general and army (as that which
they are clearly convinced, in the sight of God, is their duty to bring about, and which
they engage accordingly to see done) how firmly and freely would this oblige the hearts
and persons, the counsels and purses, the affections and prayers, with all that is in the
power of this whole party to do, in way of assistance and strengthening the hands of those
now in power, whatever straits and difficulties they may meet with in the maintenance of
the public safety and peace!
This, then, being the state of our present affairs and differences, let it be
acknowledged on all hands, and let all be convinced that are concerned, that there is not
only a possibility, but a probability, yea, a compelling necessity, of a firm union in
this great body, the setting of which in joint and tune again, by a spirit of meekness and
fear of the Lord, is the work of the present day, and will prove the only remedy under God
to uphold and carry on this blessed cause and work of the Lord in the three nations, that
is already come thus far onward in its progress to its desired and expected end of
bringing in Christ, the desire of all nations, as the chief Ruler among us.
Now unto this reuniting work let there be a readiness in all the dissenting parts from
the highest to the lowest, by cheerfully coming forth to one another in a spirit of
self-denial and love instead of war and wrath, and to cast down themselves before the
Lord, who is the father of all their spirits, in self-abasement and humiliation, for the
mutual offence they have been in, for some time past, one unto another, and great
provocation unto God, and reproach unto his most glorious name, who expected to have been
served by them with reverence and godly fear; for our God is a consuming fire.
And, as an inducement unto this, let us assure ourselves the means of effecting it will
not prove so difficult as other things that have been brought about in the late war, if
the minds and spirits of all concerned were once well and duly prepared hereunto by a
kindly work of self-denial and self-abasement, set home by the spirit of the Lord upon
their consciences, which, if he please, he may do we know not how soon: nay, we shall
behold with a discerning eye the inside of that work which God hath been doing among us
the three years last past: it would seem chiefly to have been his aim to bring his people
into such a frame as this; for in this tract of time there hath been (as we may say) a
great silence in heaven, as if God were pleased to stand still and be as a looker on, to
see what his people would be in their latter end, and what work they would make of it, if
left to their own wisdom and politic contrivances. And as God hath had the silent part, so
men, and that good men too, have had the active and busy part, and have, like themselves,
made a great sound and noise, like the shout of a king in a mighty host; which, while it
hath been a sound only and no more, hath not done much hurt as yet; but the fear and
jealousy thereby caused, hath put the whole body out of frame, and made them apt to fall
into great confusions and disorder.
And if there be thus arisen a general dissent and disagreement of parts (which is not,
nor ought to be, accounted the less considerable because it lies hid and kept in under a
patient silence), why should there not be as general a confession and acknowledgment of
what each may find themselves overtaken in, and cannot but judge themselves faulty for?
this kind of vent being much better than to have it break out in flames of a forward and
untimely wrathful spirit, which never works the righteouness of God, especially since what
hath been done among us may probably have been more the effect of temptation than the
product of any malicious design; and this sort of temptation is very common and incident
to men in power (how good soever they may be) to be overtaken in, and thereupon do sudden
unadvised actions, which the Lord pardons and overrules for the best, evidently making
appear that it is the work of the weak and fleshly part, which his own people carry about
with them too much unsubdued; and therefore the Lord thinks fit, by this means, to show
them the need of being beholden to their spiritual part to restore them again, and bring
them into their right temper and healthful constitution.
And thus, while each dissenting part is aggravating upon it self faultiness and blame,
and none excusing, but all confessing they deserve, in one sort or other, reproof, if not
before men, yet in God's sight, who knows how soon it may please God to come into this
broken, contrite, and self denying frame of spirit in the good people within the three
nations, and own them, thus truly humbled and abased, for his temple and the place of his
habitation and rest, wherein he shall abide forever? of whom it may be said, God is in the
midst of her, she shall not be moved; God shall help her, and that right early, or with
his morning appearance; at which time he will sit silent no longer, but Heaven will speak
again, and become active and powerful in the spirits and hearts of honest men, and in the
works of his providences, when either they go out to fight by sea or by land, or remain in
council and debates at home for the public weal, and again hear the prayers of his people,
and visibly own them as a flock of holy men, as Jerusalem in her solemn feasts: "I
will yet for this be inquired of by the house of Israel, saith the Lord, to do it for
them: and then they shall know that I the Lord their God am with them, and that they are
my people, and that ye my flock, the flock of my pasture, are men that have showed
yourselves weak, sinful men, and I am your God, that have declared myself an allwise and
powerful God, saith the Lord God."
Postscript
Reader, - Upon the perusal of this discourse, thou wilt quickly perceive that these two
things are principally aimed at in it by the answer in some measure that which is called
for by those in power, when they publicly profess they desire nothing more than
conviction, and to find out the hidden provocations which either have or yet may bring
forth the Lord against these nations, in the way which at present they are in.
Secondly, to remove out of the minds and spirits of the honest party, that still agree
in the reason and justice of the good old cause, all things of a private nature and
selfish concern (the tendency whereof serves but to foment and strengthen wrath and
divisions among them), and in place thereof to set before them that common and public
interest, which, if with sincerity embraced, may be the means of not only procuring a firm
union among them, but also of conserving them herein.
In order to do this, the author hath not been willing so much to declare his own
opinion, or deliver any positive conclusions, as to discuss the business by way of
question and answer, and thereby make as near a conjecture as he can of that wherein the
several dissenting parts may with better satisfaction meet together, and agree upon a safe
and righteous bottom, than to remain at the distance they do, to the apparent advantage of
the common enemy, the approaching ruin of themselves, and needless hazard, if not loss, of
the cause they have been so deeply engaged in; especially considering that, when once they
shall be found beginning to come forth to one another in such a condescending,
self-denying spirit, cleansed from the stain of hypocrisy and deceit, they may be well
assured that light will spring up among them more and more unto a perfect day; and then
those things which at present we have next in view, will prove as shadows ready to flee
away before the morning brightness of Christ's heavenly appearance and second coming,
through which they will be heightened and improved to their full maturity, to the bringing
in that kingdom of his that shall never be moved.
And because an essay hath been already made in a private way to obtain the first thing,
that is to say, conviction, which chiefly is in the hand of the Lord to give, the same
obligation lies upon the author, with respect to the second, for the exposing of it as now
it is unto public view, and therein leaving it also with the Lord for his blessing
thereunto.
